JMRI: PanelPro Frequently Asked Questions
How does JMRI tie into the rest of my layout?
Jim Betz responded with this on the JMRI User's alias when asked for an overview:
- JMRI works like a throttle - it sends and listens to the messages on the "command bus". Nothing more, nothing less. And that is actually - A LOT - and is the true beauty of JMRI. In the case of DecoderPro the commands that are being used and monitored are those related to programming a loco. In the case of PanelPro the messages/commands that are being used are those pertinent to block occupancy, turnouts, etc.
- Each system has its own "command bus" or "computer interface" - i.e. its own set of commands (think 'command format') that it uses. This is why you can't use a Digitrax throttle on an NCE system. Many people refer to the command bus as a "throttle net" - to distinguish it from the track bus. And it is important to note that the messages on the two are not identical in all cases. Some systems are similar enough to each other in order to make it possible to use a throttle from one on another ... but this is relatively rare (very few layouts actually make use of it). Another solution is CMRI - which has its own command set. JMRI also is smart enough to "speak CMRI" (as well as the ability to "speak" Digitrax and NCE and Lenz ... etc.) The difference being is that CMRI is a command set and hardware that is focused only on the RR support systems (signals, turnouts, etc.) and does not have the ability to control or program trains. And, in point of fact, does not "know" whether the layout is DC or DCC. Most of the layouts that have implemented CMRI recently have used the CMRI hardware and JMRI (PanelPro) for the human interface.
- On DCC layouts the command station is the interface between the track and the throttle/command bus. You use the throttle bus to acquire a loco ... and to send control messages to the command station - which 'forwards' your throttle changes to the locos ... and to the stationary decoders ... via either the track -or- command bus (or both).
- It is possible - some will even say desirable - to separate your train support (track bus) from your layout control support. Although it may not be intuitive - you don't have to use the same system that you use to control trains to control the turnouts and signals - simply because messages don't need to cross that boundary. This is why some have recommended you consider an environment such as NCE for the trains and CMRI or Digitrax for the layout support (PanelPro).
- Because Digitrax and CMRI have published their interfaces there are more products available for layout control for those two systems than for NCE. Both RR-CirKits and Team Digital have excellent products out that work for Digitrax (for instance). As far as I know there are no such products for NCE. I do not know what is/isn't available for Lenz.
- PanelPro is still developing at a rapid rate. Many layouts are already up and running using PanelPro - but the most recent developments that have just recently been made available in PanelPro make using it a -lot- easier than it used to be. Actually, if you are talking just turnouts and block occupancy then PanelPro has been usable for some time. Signaling is getting better all the time.
- When you start doing signaling then "everything
changes". Because signaling requires that the block
occupancy and turnout status be used in the decision
process of "what aspect should be displayed on which
signals at this point in time". This requires layout
specific code/logic. I'm assuming that you want a computer
to make these decisions. It is possible to implement a
system where a human being, usually the dispatcher, does
all of the decisions ... the more complex the
layout/signaling system the more errors the dispatcher will
make. And there is also the "workload" issue(s)... but a
computer running PanelPro is usually loafing and has more
than enough power to keep ahead of the needs of the layout.
Implementing layout control (turnouts, block occupancy, signals, etc.) is not an "easy deal". And, in my opinion, it is not something you should attempt to teach yourself - or to do it alone with just the help/guidance of online lists such as this one. I am not saying "don't use online" ... I'm saying that if you want to do this as easily as possible then you should seek out those who have gone before and enlist their face-to-face support/guidance. Yes, you can do it your self - no, that's not the best way to do this and you will find you make -many- mistakes that will cause considerable delays and rework. Many layout automation projects have gotten stalled for just this very reason.
And just so this gets mentioned ... adding capabilities such as block occupancy detection, computer controlled turnouts, and signals is not inexpensive and needs to be budgeted/spec'd out. And you may find that you will need to re-wire some or even major portions of your layout in order to support them correctly/at all.
How do I save my work?There are several ways to save your panel. This is because the program has to store both configuration (turnouts, sensors, etc) and layout (the details of your specific panel) information.
Usually, the easiest way is to use just one file to contain everything. For example, you can store your panel(s) in a file called "MainPanel.xml" (or something like that), and set the preferences to load that file. Then, all you have to do is save that file again whenever you change something. One caution: Make sure that you still have the panel open when you save the file! If you close it, then save the file, it will of course write a version of the file that doesn't show the panel. And save this file from the "Panels" menu, using the "Store Panels..." item.
Can I store just the configuration information?You can store just the "configuration" information in a file, which you can save without worrying about whether your panel(s) are open, etc. If you do this, you can also save your panels to their own, separate files.
To do this:
- Go to one of the table tools (e.g. Route Table) and pick "Store configuration..." from the "File" menu.
- This will let you select a file name; make sure it is _NOT_ the same as the panel file name. (e.g. use "MyConfig.xml" instead of "MyPanel.xml")
- Remember that name and location, then store.
Now, to ensure this configuration information automatically loads when the program starts:
- Open the preferences panel,
- check the box for "show advanced preferences", and wait a second for them to appear.
- Scroll down to "Load panel file at startup", click "Add",
- and select the file in which you have stored the configuration.
- Click "Save" on the preferences pane to make sure this is stored.
- Quit the program and restart it to test.
Where should I put my custom icons and other files?The best place to put your own files is in the JMRI Preferences directory (all JMRI apps use the same directory). You should put any locally-modified versions of files here so they don't get overwritten by a new version of the program. Any files that the program writes to contain local information, e.g. roster entries, are also written here.
The location of this varies by computer type.
- On a Linux machine, look for a .jmri directory in your home directory.
- On a Macintosh, look in the Preferences folder of the current System Folder if running MacOS 8 or 9, or the Library/Preferences folder in your user directory on Mac OS X.
- On Windows, this can be in a number of places depending on which Windows version you're running and whether you have multiple users configured; Search for a "JMRI" directory to find it.
If you have created icons that you want to be able from the panel editor, put them in a directory called "resources" in the Preferences directory. They'll then show up in the "files" part of the selection box when you press a "Change icon..." button on the panel editor.
For example, if the Preferences directory contains the files shown below, you'll get the file display shown at the right.
> ls resources/ decoderpro.gif green.gif icons red.gif tester.gif > ls resources/icons/ something tester.gif > ls resources/icons/something/ tester.gif
It's also possible to put your files in the
resources directory within the JMRI distribution
directory that you get when you install the program. This is
not recommended, because files there will likely be
overwritten when you install a future version (a newer
version of a file, perhaps to fix a problem, will overwrite
your copy; the replacement is based on the file's date). More
information about the JMRI